Choose a tool

FirstIndex alternatives and how they compare

FirstIndex is a done-for-you SEO and AI visibility service at $2,000 a month. Compare it with self-serve plans that scan, track and fix from $29 a month.

By the Why Won't AI teamPublished 3 min readAsk about this page:ChatGPTClaude
On this page

As of November 19, 2026, FirstIndex costs $2,000 a month. The first 3 months are a commitment. After that, the plan is month to month. A 12-month plan costs $1,500 a month. A one-time Search and AI report costs $1,000.

What FirstIndex does

FirstIndex (firstindex.com) is a service, not a software tool. Its team does the work for you. Each month, the plan includes up to 12 in-depth articles and 50+ fixes to the pages you have. It also includes index checks, comparison pages, free tools, directory listings and outreach pitches. FirstIndex tracks AI answers in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI each week.

FirstIndex and Why Won't AI side by side

FeatureFirstIndexWhy Won't AI
TypeDone-for-you serviceSelf-serve software, plus fixed-scope fix sprints
Entry price$2,000 a month; $1,500 a month on a 12-month planFree account; paid plans from $29 a month
Commitment3 months, then month to monthMonthly, cancel any time
Who makes the fixesThe FirstIndex teamYou or your coding agent, with GitHub pull requests we open (4 to 100 a month by plan)
ArticlesUp to 12 in-depth articles a monthArticle and comparison drafts: 4 a month on Pro, 20 on Agency
AI answer trackingWeekly, in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI answersDaily: 20 to 150 prompts by plan in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews and AI Mode. Gemini daily and Claude weekly on Pro and Agency
Crawler checkRobots.txt, sitemaps and AI crawlers are part of the planEach scan requests your pages as 6 crawlers and compares raw and rendered HTML
Site platformsNext.js, Astro, React Router and Rails; its pricing page lists WordPress, Webflow and Framer as not a fit yetScans any public site, including WordPress, Webflow, Framer, Lovable and Base44; fix pull requests need the site code on GitHub

The two options suit different buyers. FirstIndex suits a team that wants to hand off the work and has the budget. Why Won't AI suits a team that wants to see the problem and make the fixes itself, at a lower monthly cost.

When FirstIndex is the better choice

  • You do not have time to write articles or make page fixes yourself.
  • You want a team to plan keywords, write content and do outreach for you.
  • A $2,000 monthly budget and a 3-month start fit your plans.

When Why Won't AI is the better choice

  • You want to see what AI crawlers get from your site before you pay for work.
  • You or your coding agent can merge a pull request.
  • You want to start free and pay from $29 a month.

Questions

How much does FirstIndex cost?

FirstIndex's pricing page lists one plan at $2,000 a month, with a 3-month start. A 12-month plan costs $1,500 a month. A one-time report costs $1,000.

Is FirstIndex software or a service?

It is a service. The FirstIndex team does the work: articles, page fixes, comparison pages and outreach.

Does FirstIndex guarantee rankings?

No. Its pricing page says no honest provider can promise a ranking, because AI answers change from run to run. It commits to daily changes and a weekly report.

Does FirstIndex work on WordPress, Webflow or Framer?

Not yet. Its pricing page lists WordPress, Webflow and Framer as not a fit. It works best on marketing sites built on Next.js, Astro, React Router or Rails.

Can I use both?

Yes. The free Why Won't AI scan shows what AI crawlers get from your site. You can use it to check the work of any service.

Sources

  1. 1.FirstIndex pricing: checked November 19, 2026
  2. 2.FirstIndex home page: checked November 19, 2026
  3. 3.Why Won't AI pricing: plan limits